SJC Approves Leahy-Lee Electronic Communications Privacy Amendments Act
. . . Legislation Would Update 1986 Law, Protect the Privacy of Americans’ Email Communications
April 25, 2013
WASHINGTON – The Senate Judiciary Committee on Thursday favorably reported bipartisan legislation coauthored by Chairman Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) and Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah) to protect the privacy of emails, texts, social media posts and other electronic communications. Both Senators hailed the Committee’s strong bipartisan support of the Electronic Communications Privacy Act Amendments Act of 2013, which updates one of the Nation’s most important digital privacy laws.
“All Americans -- regardless of political party affiliation or ideology -- care about their privacy rights,” said Leahy, an author of the original 1986 ECPA law. “That is why Senator Lee and I are joined in this effort by a broad coalition of more than 100 privacy, civil liberties, civil rights and tech industry leaders from across the political spectrum in supporting the privacy updates contained in this bill.”
"Reforming ECPA to protect legitimate privacy rights is not a partisan issue," said Senator Lee. "I'm pleased to be working closely with Chairman Leahy to help ensure that all Americans can be confident that the government may not access their email or other electronic communications without a warrant."
The Leahy-Lee Electronic Communications Privacy Act Amendments Act of 2013 establishes a search warrant requirement in order for the government to obtain the content of Americans’ emails and other electronic communications, when those communications are stored with a third-party service provider. The bill eliminates the outdated “180-day” rule that calls for different legal standards for the government to obtain email content depending upon the age of an email, and it requires that the government notify an individual whose electronic communications have been disclosed within 10 days of obtaining a search warrant. The Committee also on Thursday adopted two amendments to the bill; a technical amendment offered by Chairman Leahy to clarify the rule of construction, and an amendment from Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) requiring the Comptroller General to conduct a review of the use of the law.
ECPA reform was the subject of two Committee hearings in recent years, and the Senate Judiciary Committee last November favorably reported legislation substantially similar to the Leahy-Lee bill. In January, Leahy said that updating ECPA was his top privacy priority for the 113th Congress.
“When I led the effort to write ECPA 27 years ago, email was a novelty,” said Leahy. “Three decades later, we must update this law, so that the law protects our privacy rights and keeps pace with innovation and the challenging mission of law enforcement. I look forward to the Senate now considering this important legislation.”
# # # # #
Statement Of Senator Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.),
Chairman, Senate Committee On The Judiciary,
On Committee Consideration Of
The Electronic Communications Privacy Act Amendments Act of 2013
April 25, 2013
Today, the Committee should complete consideration of important bipartisan legislation that I spoke about last week to better protect Americans’ digital privacy. The Leahy-Lee Electronic Communications Privacy Act Amendments Act will strengthen the privacy protections for our email and other electronic communications, to meet the challenges of the digital age. I thank Senator Lee for cosponsoring this important privacy bill. We understand that protecting Americans’ privacy rights is something that is important to all Americans, regardless of political party or ideology. I hope that all Senators on the Committee will share this view and support this important privacy legislation.
Last year, this Committee favorably reported substantially similar legislation with strong bipartisan support. We did so amidst growing concern among many Americans about the unwarranted intrusions into our private lives in cyberspace. Many Americans are concerned that the Internal Revenue Service, or other government agencies, may be reading their email without first obtaining a search warrant.
When I led the effort to write ECPA 27 years ago, email was a novelty. No one could have imagined the way the Internet and mobile technologies would transform how we communicate and exchange information today. Three decades later, we must update this law, so that the law protects our privacy rights and keeps pace with innovation and the challenging mission of law enforcement.
The bill takes several important steps to accomplish this. First, the bill requires that the Government obtain a search warrant based on probable cause to obtain the content of Americans’ email and other electronic communications, when those communications are requested from a third-party service provider. There are exceptions to the warrant requirement for emergency circumstances and to protect national security.
Second, the bill requires that the Government promptly notify any individual whose email content has been accessed via a third-party service provider, and provide that individual with a copy of the search warrant and other details about the information obtained. The bill permits the Government to seek a court order temporarily delaying such notice in order to protect the integrity of ongoing Government investigations. In addition, the bill permits the Government to ask a court to temporarily preclude a service provider from notifying a customer about the disclosure.
The bill also contains several important provisions to ensure that the reforms to ECPA do not hinder law enforcement. The bill adds a new notice requirement to the law that requires service providers to notify the Government of their intent to inform a customer about a disclosure of electronic communications information at least three business days before giving such notice. Furthermore, to help law enforcement investigate and prosecute corporate wrongdoing, the bill adds civil discovery subpoenas to the existing tools that the Government may use to obtain non-content information under ECPA.
Our bill allows the Government to continue to use administrative, civil discovery and grand jury subpoenas to obtain corporate email and other electronic communications directly from a corporate entity, when those communications are contained on an internal email system. Lastly, the bill also provides that the search warrant requirement in the bill does not apply to other Federal criminal or national security laws, including Title III of the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1986 (commonly known as the “Wiretap Act”) and the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978 (50 U.S.C. § 1801, et seq. (commonly known as “FISA”)).
After years of work on ECPA reform, the time has come for the Congress to enact these commonsense privacy reforms. We have held two hearings on ECPA reform and the Committee spent several weeks considering ECPA reform legislation last year. Since I first put forward proposals to update ECPA in early 2011, I have worked to make sure that these updates carefully balance privacy interests, the needs of law enforcement and the interests of our thriving American tech sector. I have consulted with those from the Federal, state and local law enforcement communities, and with many leaders in the privacy, civil liberties, civil rights and technology communities.
Enacting these privacy reforms should not be a partisan issue. All Americans -- regardless of political party affiliation or ideology -- care about their privacy rights. That is why Senator Lee and I are joined in this effort by a broad coalition of more than 100 privacy, civil liberties, civil rights and tech industry leaders from across the political spectrum that have also endorsed this bill. Liberal organizations such as the American Civil Liberties Union and the Center for Democracy and Technology have joined with conservative organizations such as Americans for Tax Reform and the Heritage Foundation to press for these reforms. I thank all of them for their support. I hope that all Members of this Committee will vote to favorably report this good privacy bill today.
# # # # #
- Bipartisan Group of Senators Push for Equity in Law Enforcement Act, April 15, 2015
- Statement of Senator Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.), Ranking Member, Senate Judiciary Committee, On the Nomination of Loretta Lynch to be Attorney General of the United States, April 15, 2015
- Statement of Senator Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) Ranking Member, Senate Judiciary Committee, Hearing on “The Need to Reform Asset Forfeiture”, April 15, 2015
- Ahead of Tax Day, Leahy Proposes Trio of Tax Credit Bills, April 14, 2015